• 50 Years - A Million Thanks
NEW YORK VOICES
home feature story archive
feedback featured voices about the series
Election 2002
Upstate / Downstate

Governor's Race 2002

When life-long New York City resident Ed Koch ran for governor in 1982, he made an errant remark about living in rural areas, where people have "to drive 20 miles to buy a gingham dress or a Sears, Roebuck suit." THE ALBANY TIMES-UNION summed up the comment in a headline: "Ed Koch to Albany: Drop Dead." In a 1998 upstate GOP ad, a swarm of sharks were shown emerging from the city and preparing to devour the rest of the state.

Photo of Carl McCall
Carl McCall (D)

The upstate/downstate rift is about more than just cultural snobbery and campaign rhetoric. Since the early eighteenth century, when urban merchants and upstate farmers first quarreled over taxes and trade regulations, governing New York has involved balancing the interests of a massively complex city with those of a largely rural state.

Photo of Tom Golisano
Tom Golisano (I)

As with all state elections in New York, this tension serves as a backdrop to the 2002 governor's race. It's at the heart of a controversy over which part of the state receives more education money from Albany; how to revitalize lower Manhattan without giving the flagging upstate economy short shrift; and how best to deal with a budget shortfall predicted to range anywhere from $5 to $10 billion. With the current recession, the conflict between New York City and upstate is in high relief.

Thirteen/WNET New York and WXXI in Rochester have collaborated on a project with two aims. First, to shed light on the issues that divide New Yorkers and help citizens make informed voting decisions in a critical gubernatorial race. Second, to point out the unique differences and similarities between upstate and downstate voters.

Photo of Governor George Pataki
George Pataki (R)

Watch for a series of spots that give voters from all over New York the opportunity to talk about Albany politics in plain English. We'll then ask the candidates how they would address those issues as governor.

In addition, two half-hour specials with the upstate/downstate views, interviews with candidates, and vignettes about specific issues will air on Thirteen/WNET on Friday, October 18 and October 25 at 10:30 PM, and then again back-to-back on Sunday, November 3 at 12:30 PM.

Governor George Pataki declined to give us an interview, but for an excellent summary of his positions click on issues 2002.

For more information about the gubernatorial election and other races, visit New York Citizens, a collaboration of public television and radio stations from across the state. It is devoted to baseline information about state issues, lawmaker contacts, and political news and issues.

For detailed and up-to-date summaries of what's happening on the campaign trail and other election information, visit GOTHAM GAZETTE's Eye on Albany.



Send Us Your Feedback!
this week's highlights
Upstate New Yorker state residence
Modem button
Cable Button
Go to Feature Storys

1) The Budget:
The state is expected to have a budget shortfall of anywhere from $5 to $10 billion next fiscal year. Should the next governor address this problem by raising taxes or by cutting spending?
(more...)

Two New York City Residence
Modem button
Cable Button
Go to Feature Storys


2) Lower Manhattan:
Would you support the use of increased tax dollars for the rebuilding of lower Manhattan?
(more...)


Photo of New York Residence
Modem button
Cable Button
Go to Feature Storys


3) Drug Laws:
Do you think the next Governor should work to repeal the Rockefeller drug laws?
(more...)


New York City Resident
Modem button
Cable Button
Go to Feature Storys


4) Education:
Would you be in favor of a tax increase for education?
(more...)


Photo of New York Residence
Modem button
Cable Button
Go to Feature Storys


3) Minimum Wage:
Do you think the next Governor should work to repeal the Rockefeller drug laws?
(more...)


this week's highlights

Upstate Residence
Modem button
Cable Button
Go to Feature Storys

Would downstaters consider living in upstate New York? Would upstaters ever live downstate?


Thirteen WNET New York