THIRTEEN PBS
THIRTEEN
THIRTEEN ARCHIVE

Thirteen’s Most Shocking Moments
Monday, March 23rd, 2009

In our over 45 years on-air, Thirteen’s thought-provoking programs have stoked debate (and sometimes fury), but they are always about ideas and free speech, challenging viewers to consider new perspectives. The buzz surrounding Sir Ian McKellen’s nude scene in Great Performances’ King Lear (March 25, 8:00 pm), and whether or not he would disrobe during the broadcast, is just the latest example of controversy that can follow programs on Thirteen and public television. (As the Washington Post reported, Sir Ian disrobed when filming the scene, but the Royal Shakespeare Company chose not to include it in Wednesday’s broadcast as an aesthetic decision.)

While some programs would still strike a nerve if aired today, most serve as a reminder that what society deems decent and appropriate changes over time and, more often than not, Thirteen led the charge.

Whether you liked the programs or not (and we’re going to assume you had pretty strong feelings one way or another), we hope you enjoy a look back at our favorite PBS shockers, which drew lots of (sometimes unwanted) attention.

June 25, 1968 – The Hippies Take Thirteen

A panel discussion on the “underground press” on Newsfront, a nightly news program, erupted into chaos when, according to The New York Times, approximately “20 hippies broke into the studios of Channel 13″ and disrupted the live broadcast as they “shouted at the panelists and at one another, often using obscenities, which were heard over the air.” Astronaut John Glenn, a guest on the show, said of the chaos, “And they say there is violence on commercial television.” Thirteen didn’t stop broadcasting their signal (the broadcast was live), giving the small band of protesters an unedited megaphone to millions of New Yorkers.

November 6, 1977 - I Claudius

In 1977, the BBCTV adaptation of the Robert Graves novels aired on Masterpiece Theater included scenes of orgies, nymphomania, adultery and incest. In their preview, The New York Times noted that the airing would “test the boundaries of public broadcasting.” Host Alistair Cooke introduced the series, and warned viewers of the sexual content. Reportedly, no PBS stations refused to carry the program.

Watch a clip here.

January 31, 1982 - Let Poland Be Poland

How many programs aired only due to an act of Congress? Let Poland be Poland was produced by the federal government’s International Communication Agency (known now as the U.S. Information Agency) and by law, could not be distributed to U.S. networks. Congress, however, passed an exemption for this program, which aimed to build support for the Polish solidarity movement. The program was labeled by many as U.S. propaganda, prompting a number of PBS stations and some international networks not to air it, though Thirteen did.

Time Magazine wrote about it.

November 24, 1983 - Mr. Hooper’s Death on Sesame Street

When beloved Sesame Street star Will Lee, who portrayed Mr. Hooper, passed away in December of 1982, the show faced the task of presenting death to young viewers. Sesame Street addressed the issue head on, used the word “death” and explained that it meant Mr. Hooper would never come back.

Watch the emotional scene here.

September 6, 1989 - Days of Rage draws protesters

A documentary about the Palestinians aired on Thirteen despite objections from thousands of viewers (and protests outside of Thirteen’s offices) about the film’s pro-Palestinian point of view. In response, PBS aired wraparound programming, including Israeli views on the Intifada and a roundtable discussion following the film. After the program aired, the filmmaker was accused of accepting money to produce the film from Arab sources. PBS guidelines bar financing of documentaries by those with a vested interest in the views expressed in the films.

Read the The New York Times’ review.

June 23, 1990 - Tongues Untied

In 1991, explicit language and homosexual subject matter caused many public television stations not to air this award-winning documentary about gay black men, broadcast as part of the P.O.V. series. Thirteen aired the unedited version numerous times and received both complaints and support for leaving the decision to view the program in the hands of viewers themselves.

P.O.V.’s series producer reminisces.

November 11, 1992 - The Liberators: Fighting on Two Fronts in World War II

Leading up to the program’s air date, accolades were heaped upon the inspiring story of all-black army units who helped liberate the Buchenwald and Dachau concentration camps. The program was praised for reporting a story ‘not found in standard historical accounts.’ Unfortunately, it’s likely the reason this impressive story had not been reported before was that certain events the film described were false. Despite the criticism, the program received an Oscar nomination for best Documentary Feature.

The NY Times discussed the aftermath.

September 4, 1994 - Tales of the City

Amid the controversy surrounding the homosexual themes, nudity, and illicit drug use in the miniseries based on Armistead Maupin’s books, PBS offered stations an edited version in which male and female body parts were obscured by pixilation. Despite the ratings success, PBS announced it would not participate in the television production of the miniseries’ sequel, More Tales of the City, and drew criticism, including from The New York Times’ op-ed page, where then PBS President Ervin Duggan was accused of “acting as a censor to appease the fundamentalism and homophobia of family-values kooks.”

2003-2005 - Kenneth Tomlinson targets Bill Moyers

After being appointed Chairman of the Corporation for Public Broadcasting in September 2003, Ken Tomlinson was soon accused of pushing a conservative agenda and threatening PBS’ editorial independence. Concerned the PBS program NOW with Bill Moyers had “liberal” leanings, Tomlinson appointed an outside consultant to monitor the program. Moyers resigned in 2005 after more than three decades as a PBS mainstay, citing political pressure to alter the content of his program. Moyers returned to host Bill Moyers Journal in 2007 after Tomlinson resigned. David Brancaccio took over as host of NOW on PBS.

March 23, 2005 - No Postcards from Buster (at least not from Vermont…)

Facing strong opposition, including that of Education Secretary Margaret Spellings, PBS decided not to distribute a scheduled episode of the children’s program Buster, where, on a trip Vermont, the title character meets children with lesbian parents. Despite the PBS decision not to distribute the episode, a number of member stations, including Thirteen, aired it.

The New York Times weighed in.

September - October 2007 - The SNAFU over Ken Burns’ The War

PBS feared huge FCC fines for airing Ken Burns’ The War, which contained explicit language. In response, the documentary was offered to affiliates in two versions: One that included profanity generally prohibited by FCC regulations (including explanations of the salty acronyms FUBAR and SNAFU) and one without profanity. Thirteen risked (and ultimately avoided) any fines and aired the unedited version.

Get more series info.

November 13, 2007 - Judgment Day: Intelligent Design on Trial

Any time you mention the words “Darwin” and “evolution,” you’re bound to hear some criticism. This episode of NOVA focused on a 2005 trial in a small Pennsylvania town where a school board member attempted to introduce a text teaching intelligent design into the science curriculum. When the board voted against the measure and instead, required biology teachers to read a prepared statement citing flaws in Darwin’s theories, lawsuits emerged. When the program aired, as it did on Thirteen, it was widely criticized by the religious right as being too pro-Darwin/evolution.

Watch the full program online.

share | Comments (22)    Email    Print   

22 responses
Larry -- March 23rd, 2009 at 4:05 pm

You didn’t mention the bare breast in Brideshead Rivisited. Certainly more revealing than the “wardrobe malfunction”.
Why is it that violance is so tolerated but showing some human anatomy which many people have seen since soon after birth is not tolerated.

Oh Well

christopher -- March 23rd, 2009 at 4:33 pm

This is not a record to be proud of. -a real jellyfish waltz.

David Van Taylor -- March 23rd, 2009 at 4:39 pm

I’m impressed that Thirteen is trumpeting their courage, while not shying say from the less-than courageous moments. Transparency is a good value for public television to model and promote. Thanks.

norman zelvin -- March 23rd, 2009 at 4:46 pm

Once a few Elementary school kids learn at home some of sexual conditions actions words and similar the information makes the “rounds “. Banning it just gives it a risque conotation as would be expected .

Chris -- March 23rd, 2009 at 4:49 pm

I’m glad to see that PBS (Thirteen) favors free speech and is against censorship. Not everything should be watered down and sanatized for public viewing. Give the viewer the freedom to watch or not watch something.

Herb NEEDLMAN -- March 23rd, 2009 at 4:53 pm

YOUR POSTING OF THE”IMPORTANT” EVENTS WILL HELP TO KEEP MINDS OPEN AND WORKING

George LaRoza -- March 23rd, 2009 at 4:54 pm

Particularly in view of the lack of adequate finances you cite on TV why not show us again all the great old series such as “Riley Ace of Spies”, “I Claudius”, “To Serve Them All My Days”, etc., etc. They were all great, and there must be a whole new group of viewers who don’t know these classics.

Chris Albertson -- March 23rd, 2009 at 5:03 pm

Channel 13 has come a long way since the mid-Sixties when I, as general manager of Pacifica station WBAI, received an extraordinary call from one of its producers. “We need to borrow one of your Negroes,” he said! Ch. 13 had secured an interview w. H. Rap Brown, who insisted on the interviewer being black. 13 had no black person for the task. I lent them Charles Hobson, who was new to radio,having come from a position as assistant carpet buyer at Stern’s department store. Charles later became a PBS TV producer.

Eugene Gorrin -- March 23rd, 2009 at 5:06 pm

Let’s not forget the play “Steambath” with a nude Valerie Perrine enjoying a nice shower, the cavorting “Moll Flanders” starring Alex Kingston, or even the series “Poldark.”

Richard Guenther -- March 23rd, 2009 at 5:14 pm

I’m no expert on Shakespeare, but would it even be realistically possible to understand “King Lear” without having seen a naked man walking back and forth in front of you? I mean, you just cannot leave that out or else the entire thing might as well be shelved! King Lear used to do jumping jacks first thing every morning, I know that much! In the nude, of course. And that is simply that.

Andrew -- March 23rd, 2009 at 5:19 pm

I’m 45 and haven’t seen many of the programs people have mentioned… would it be possible to do a ‘retro night’ where you show some of the more classic series??

susanc -- March 23rd, 2009 at 7:16 pm

Decades ago, Thirteen aired a documentary on Ian McKellen in which he took a shower and it showed him totally, frontaly nude. Apparently we are going backward

Mrs. H. A. Clark -- March 23rd, 2009 at 8:39 pm

Thanks, George. Am cutting & pasting your comment (if it will be allowed), much easier than going back & forth. LOVED the series mentioned plus many more. Since the U.S. is in financial ill health, save money by reairing: “Riley Ace of Spies”, “I Claudius”, “To Serve Them All My Days”, etc., etc. You’ll save money while we’ll enjoy.

Melissa Murray-Bance -- March 23rd, 2009 at 9:02 pm

I love the idea of reshowing these ’shock’ shows as I too am sorry to say that I have missed several and would enjoy the retro experience too! Many thanks for the list!

Richard -- March 23rd, 2009 at 10:55 pm

Intelligent design is a joke. It is based on religion, and religion is antiquated. We are in the 21st century, medieval times.

Alencon -- March 23rd, 2009 at 11:06 pm

The program “Judgement Day: Intelligent Design on Trial” was “criticized by the religious right as being too pro-Darwin/evolution.”

Isn’t that sort of like being criticized for being “pro-truth?” Can someone please tell me how we make the religious right wackos go away?

Jan Baybusky -- March 24th, 2009 at 10:23 am

If PBS can’t be brave enough to show these shows as they were made with nude scenes, strong language, etc. then who can? Not everyone can afford cable. Some of the shows on network TV are disgusting but because there is no nudity or foul language, they go out to everyone. I, Claudius and Brideshead were two of the very best shows on TV. Yet when I, Claudius was shown in reruns, it was cut. Yes, PBS denied it but I had taped the original shows and know it was so. So, if we can’t count on PBS to be brave enough to shows as they were made, then PBS will lost many contributions. And, by the way, the religious right wackos will never go away - as demonstrated by the Baptist Church that condemned Vanessa Redgrave to Hell!

Rhea Massaro -- March 24th, 2009 at 6:35 pm

I noticed my favorite commentator Bill Moyers,On “Bill Moyers Journal” is not quite the same, honest & straight-forward liberal as he was on NOW. We all loved him very much. We always knew we would get the truth without the candy coating from him He just isn’t the same anymore. Come back Bill, we need you.

Bill H -- March 24th, 2009 at 9:16 pm

Late one evening, during one of your fund raisers, back in about 1972 or 1973 you aired an experimental video. The image of the modern dancers started wrapping through itself and around the virtual back of the screen, like a Mobieus strip. After a couple of minutes the dancers started to emerge out of nowhere in the nude. The broadcast was not interrupted, and when the video was done, the MC said “Well, I guess that was the 11 o’clock nudes”

Rory Neumann -- March 24th, 2009 at 10:51 pm

Two weeks ago Thirteen aired a program American Experience about a man named Oppenheimer who developed the Atom Bomb..unfortunately, I missed it…can you please run it again….Thank you in advance…

Larry -- April 2nd, 2009 at 1:04 pm

And to think , at one time the presentation of “Steambath” , with some bare breast shots, caused a huge controversy.

Christine -- April 6th, 2009 at 2:17 am

Please bring back “I Claudius” & any issues
of “Frontline” possible, the mix of realism
with historical portrayals makes great TV!!
Thank you for your courageous productions!

post a comment
Please note that the THIRTEEN editorial staff reserves the right to not post comments it deems to be inappropriate and/or malicious in nature, as well as edit comments for length, clarity and fairness. No solicitations or advertisements will be allowed. Users may link to other Web sites relevant to discussion, but most often links to commercial Web sites will not be permitted.

Yes, send me THIRTEEN Highlights by email

home donate schedule video programs kids for educators shop
about THIRTEEN producing for THIRTEEN announcements archives career opportunities internships pbs.org privacy policy pressroom contact
©2009 WNET.ORG Properties, LLC All Rights Reserved.    450 West 33rd Street    New York, NY 10001    visit WNET.ORG
©2009 WNET.ORG Properties, LLC All Rights Reserved.    450 West 33rd Street    New York, NY 10001    visit WNET.ORG